Should You Pay Off Debts or Invest Your Money?

Educate > Investing

More Resources

Table of Contents

Should You Pay Off Debts or Invest Your Money?

If you want to improve your financial situation, paying off debts and investing your money should be among your top priorities. However, you may only have the resources to commit to one of these goals at a time, and that may leave you wondering which one is more important.

In this quick guide, you’ll explore why it’s so important to make a choice and which choice is more likely to be the best one depending on your circumstances. You’ll learn about different types of debt, why debt resolution is often preferable, and when investing first is the right move.

When Should You Focus on Paying Off Debt over Saving?

Paying off your debts should be your priority in most situations. The simplest reason for this is that interest rates on debt are typically higher than interest rates on investments. Though there are exceptions, you will nearly always save money in the long run by resolving debts first.

It’s possible to determine what you can save by paying off your interest early. In fact, your loan documents should clarify what you will owe over the lifetime of your loan by making only the minimum payments. You can use your existing interest rate and a repayment calculator to find out exactly how much you can save.

High-Interest Debt Should Be Your Highest Priority

If you’ve decided that you need to focus on your debt first, you should start with the riskiest types of debt while making minimum payments on your low-interest debt. In most cases, the riskiest types of debt are credit card debt, personal debt, and delinquent debt.

Credit Card Debt

Nearly all financial experts will recommend that you pay off credit card debt before you focus on investments or other kinds of debts. Credit card debt carries some of the highest interest rates, and these rates are rarely matched by typical investments.

On top of the high-interest rates, credit card interest typically compounds daily. This means the balances will grow faster than other types of debt.

Personal Loans

After credit cards, unsecured personal loans and lines of credit are likely to have the highest interest rates among other types of debt. Like credit card debt, personal loans can have a large impact on your credit score.

Delinquent Debts

Debts are considered delinquent when they are past due or have been submitted to collections. Any delinquent debt is likely to incur higher interest rates and additional fees that will be added to the principal loan amount. Penalty rates on delinquent debts can be even higher than those on credit card debt.

Saving money in the long term is one great reason to focus on your loan payments first, but it’s not the only one. Debt can come with other serious consequences for your life, including psychological risks.

Long-Term Debt Comes with Psychological Risks

Another reason to give debt the first priority is the effect it can have on your life. Debts can cause serious psychological strain that becomes an obstacle to all your other goals.

As a result of your debts, you may struggle with shame or feelings of inadequacy. These feelings can build into long-term depression that interferes with your earning potential and can leave you facing even more debts in the long run.

Depression isn’t even the only problem behavior that results from debt.

Many people who are trapped in debt become more prone to risky behavior as they become worn down by the worry. This can make dangerous financial decisions like gambling “feel” necessary, even when the behavior is likely to make the problem worse.

Even experts agree that debt can cause serious psychological strain.

“Dr. Mark Aoyagi, a professor at the University of Denver's Graduate School of Professional Psychology, explains that while short-term stress can sharpen our focus, chronic stress does the opposite — it drains mental energy and narrows our ability to think clearly.

Debt-related stress often creates a "constant pull on our attention," making it difficult to focus on other aspects of life, such as work, relationships, or personal goals.

Paying off debt is worth it just to avoid these pressures. When debts are paid off, the relief can come with benefits you may not expect.

Are there Other Benefits to Paying off Debt Early?

Yes, there are other benefits to prioritizing your debts over investments. There are many more benefits than can be listed here, but below are some examples that are likely to have the most significant impact on your life.

Reduced Daily Stress

Debt is a significant source of daily stress. Money remains the top source of stress for Canadians, according to the 2026 FP Canada Financial Stress Index. This stress can have all sorts of additional effects, including ruining your sleep. Resolving your debts can help you achieve fast relief from these symptoms.

Improved Relationships

Numerous studies have shown that debt can come with serious consequences for your relationships. For example, a recent study found that “40 percent (of couples in relationships with debt) say that this financial burden ends up having a negative impact on their relationships.”

The same study found “couples who are concerned about paying down debt are also more likely to suffer from poor communication, fighting, and difficulty having conversations about money.”

Another study found that fighting over finances is one of the top predictors of divorce. Resolving debt more quickly can help you prevent relationship troubles.

Better Maneuverability During Emergencies

Paying off your debts early can leave you in a significantly better position if you need to deal with other financial emergencies or simply set up an emergency fund.

Remember, debts often become even worse if you don’t pay them on time, but that’s not always an option if you’re dealing with an emergency.

Clearing out your debts means there’s one less source you have to worry about when you need all of your money to handle something like a disabled vehicle or an urgent need to travel to see friends or relatives who are dealing with emergencies.

Being debt-free also gives you more room for retirement planning.

Improved Employment Opportunities

Paying off your debts early can improve your career outlook in several important ways.

First, if you’re dealing with dangerous amounts of debt, you’re probably going to be locked into the job you have now. It will be risky to attempt to jump jobs or risk a gap in your employment that could leave you unable to make your debt payments.

Dealing with debt will also make it more difficult for you to focus on the job you have right now. You’re unlikely to have the focus you need to impress supervisors in your current position or in any interviews you schedule for other positions.

While rare, some positions consider credit scores when conducting background checks. You may be ineligible for some jobs if you have excessive debt or if your debt has caused your credit score to dip below a level that’s unacceptable for high-security roles in finance, security, government, or corporate funds.

Regaining Your Financial Freedom

One of the greatest benefits of paying off your debts early is regaining control of your personal cash flow. Obviously, you want to have funds available for the things that excite you the most.

Having to pay off serious debts first means you will be forced to miss opportunity after opportunity to fund your hobbies, travel to your favorite destinations, or make key upgrades to your home or vehicle. You’ll also get to enjoy the relief of rebuilding your savings account and the thrill of getting to make interesting moves in the stock market.

It can be difficult to imagine the relief you’ll feel when you’re finally able to spend on yourself again.

With so many advantages to paying off your debts early, it may be difficult to imagine why investing may be a superior option. However, there are definitely some situations where that’s the better move. Next, you’ll learn about some of the reasons to choose investing first.

Sometimes, Investing May Be the Better Financial Move

While financial experts generally agree that you should focus on your debts first, there are exceptions. In some situations, it may be a better idea to invest than to pay down your debts.

Here are some examples of situations where investing offers you advantages.

When an investment opportunity offers a superior interest rate

It is true that interest rates on debt are typically higher than interest rates on investments, but that is not always the case. Some rare opportunities may give you the chance to earn significantly more than you’d save by focusing on your debt first.

You can recognize these opportunities simply by comparing the interest rates on your debts to the returns your investments offer. If you can earn significantly more on the investment, it’s probably wise to do so.

When matching and other advantages are available

Some employers in Canada may offer matching funds for your retirement savings. When matching funds are available, all of your contributions are increased (sometimes doubled) up to a point.

When there are opportunities for compound growth

Savings become more valuable the longer they accumulate and compound. For that reason, it can be a good idea to save more when you are younger and still building up your savings.

When there are penalties for prepayment

You will not be rewarded for paying off all types of debt early. Some debts have contractual penalties for paying early. You can find these penalties listed in your contract if they apply to you.

When you may need liquid cash for emergencies

If you have any emergencies on the horizon, you should put your liquid cash into investments rather than into debt. As long as the money is invested, you can quickly retrieve it as soon as you need it. If you put it toward your debts, it’s just gone unless you take out even more debt (that may not be an option).

Have More Questions? Contact My Canada Payday Today

Now, you understand what you need to consider when choosing between paying off your debts and saving for the future. As you’ve learned, this is a complex question that can have many different answers depending on your life circumstances.

In most cases, you will want to focus on your debts. This is the choice that will save you more money in the long run. It’s also the choice that can help you avoid psychological stress and negative consequences in your life.

While it’s best to avoid debt, you may sometimes need a quick loan to help you get through hard times. When you need money fast, even if you have a poor credit score, you should consider the range of personal loans offered by My Canada Payday.